David Garcia via nettime-l on Fri, 20 Nov 2026 18:42:08 +0100 (CET)


[Date Prev] [Date Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

Re: <nettime> Falling into the Breach


Another item on your list on the road to Hell I would add is:
- AI blurs and so weakens lines of accountability.

In his article on documentary NAZA (about Israel's AI enabled killing machine and system for calculating "collateral" damage) Eyal Weizman, writing in the London Review of Books, describes how Daniel Reisner, chief legal adviser in the Israeli army before he died in July, became frustrated with the vagueness of the concept of proportionality in warfare. Proportionality, he argued, doesn’t ‘tell us what to include in the calculation, what is the equation and what is the exchange rate’?

He thought armies needed simple formulas and exact numbers to be able to act quickly and efficiently ‘in real-time situations’. He was trying to develop what he described to Weizman 15 years ago, as ‘mathematical tools to tackle the problem. He believed that letting computers make the calculations was more *ethical* than leaving it to humans, because machines aren’t subject to human bias and aren’t corrupted by the desire for revenge, cruelty or excess.

One of the interviewee/operatives in the movie shares Reisner's position, telling co-director Abraham that ‘it’s better that the AI takes the decision rather than a person whose friend was just killed.’

David Garcia

On 2026-11-18 16:03, Felix Stalder via nettime-l wrote:
I think AI plays into this on multiple levels, but I'm not sure the attack level is the most significant at the moment.

- Bosses have been convinced that they could fire IT staff, replacing them with AI, leaving many orgs critically understaffed and with fading institutional memory.

- Weakening of regulatory oversight, and a culture of no-accountability, even before Trump introduced rampant cronyism. No software company was ever fined for a security breach or system failure (as far as I know).

- AI has been able to uncover many long existing vulnerabilities. Security by obscurity no longer works, putting a lot of pressure on orgs to patch their systems. Probably their IT departments warned about some of those issues for a long time, but now AI says it, so management listens.

- AI shortens the time between vulnerability detected and exploit deployed, putting even more pressure in the orgs.

- Patches are vibe-coded and/or rolled out at high speeds with insufficient testing, making the systems unstable in unforeseen ways.

For well-maintained clearly bounded projects such as the Linux Kernel, this is a manageable process that might result in improved software, for large, sprawling infrastructures, where many systems are hobbled together, this is a real problem.


all the best. Felix

On 18/11/2026 19:34, Brian Holmes via nettime-l wrote:
Ted wrote:

"Institutionalist analyses read well because they can seem on their face so
concrete and specific. But in this one I’m definitely taking the
culturalist view. It doesn’t negate the things you’ve mentioned (and legal frameworks are definitely institutionalist in nature), it just situates them more meaningfully in something like a Geertzian thick description."

I am definitely in favor of the thick description. I am currently reading about the concept of pre-compliance (aka anticipatory obedience) which is used to analyze the combined phenomena of information control in the press and direct repression by civil society actors (museum boards, university officials, Silicon Valley firms etc). Pre-compliance has a long history, stretching back through 9/11 to the Cold War. So yeah, no objection at all,
we're just onto different aspects.

Probably I am more ignorant than many of you as to the geeky stuff. But since we have before our eyes what looks like a big pre-compliance event in the press, I am fascinated by what is not being talked about: the technical
details of AI-enabled hacking, plus the more familiar structure of
arms-length support by states for those kinds of cyber-attacks.
Interestingly the NY Times has only one mention of ARTEX (a month ago), and
they seem to have said nothing about the Optimizely intrusion, another
major hack that took place the day before yesterday. While the state fails
and the media obfuscates, the situation grows more extreme.

The development of AI has created an emergency situation: not rogue agents but super-empowered human actors. The Trump administration is choking off news about it and the media are complying with state control. Maybe they're
afraid of popular panic? On the ground and even in the air, we are all
sitting ducks for whatever may happen.

curiously, Brian

On Wed, Nov 18, 2026 at 10:20 AM GM - tedbyfield <tedbyfield@gmail.com>
wrote:

I’m not sure how you could read my litany of breakdowns and could go on to say so affirmatively that it misses a few key things, but you do you. The legal frameworks you mention are important, sure, but to say they’re key suggests that the rule of of law prevails — but *the defining feature* of Trump 2 is that the rule of law does *not* apply. Innocent parties are harassed with lawfare, guilty parties are rewarded and honored, existing laws are ignored, and imaginary laws are imposed ruthlessly — all according
to a ‘logic’ so wildly erratic that to call it hormonal would be too
generous. If a company actively violated one of the legal frameworks you mention but did so in ways that actively supported the whims of Trump & Co, the biggest risk they’d run by far would be the inviolable principle that everything Trump touched dies sooner or later. So, sure, those laws are a factor in companies’ decision to remain silent, but they won’t be the first thing that comes to mind in the C-suite (or even the counsel’s office, I’d
wager). And I say that on the basis of decades of paying pretty close
attention to how various entities in digital security have navigated the
shifting boundaries of compliance, disclosure, etc.

Also: the litany of breakdowns in my last mail left out a *huge* factor in this context — the Trumpian attack on higher ed. The resulting pressure in HE to keep your head down and your moiuth shut has become excruciating across the board, but in sensitive areas — constitutional law, for example — it doesn’t matter which way someone throws the dice, they *will* lose. If they don’t run afoul of Trump & Co, they’ll get spanked by admins who live in terror of the Eye of Sauron will fall on their institution, or
incur the mistrust of their colleagues and peers.

Historically, compsec has relied *very* heavily on academic research for a variety of reasons — clearly structured areas of expertise, an equitable issue-driven approach, rigorous standards, noncommercial incentives, legal protections related to educational contexts, and so on. That old-school (so to speak) system — exemplified by orgs like CERT at CMU, Spafford’s COAST at Purdue, UC Davis’s Computer Security Lab, etc — has been breaking down for quite a while, but now it seems to be dead. In fields like this, HE researchers were like honeybees who could cross boundaries of every kind, building networks and encouraging productively open exchange, but now not.

More generally, I’ve been noticing more and more that discussions like
this tend to break down on institutionalist vs culturalist lines.
Institutionalist analyses read well because they can seem on their face so
concrete and specific. But in this one I’m definitely taking the
culturalist view. It doesn’t negate the things you’ve mentioned (and legal frameworks are definitely institutionalist in nature), it just situates them more meaningfully in something like a Geertzian thick description.

Ted

On 18 Nov 2026, at 10:02, Brian Holmes via nettime-l wrote:

Folks, I totally agree that the infrastructure in the US is old and the administration is vastly incompetent, making even very important systems like air traffic control uniquely vulnerable. But the observation misses
two key things about the present situation.

The first is that there is very likely a reason for the current confusion: it's because US officials and their private contractors are legally barred from speaking about cybersecurity events, due to legal frameworks like
these:

<. . .>


--
| |||||||||||||||| http://felix.openflows.com |
| |||||||||| https://tldr.nettime.org/@festal |
| for secure communication, please use signal |
--
# distributed via <nettime>: no commercial use without permission
# <nettime> is a moderated mailing list for net criticism,
# collaborative text filtering and cultural politics of the nets
# more info: https://www.nettime.org
# contact: nettime-l-owner@lists.nettime.org